What’s the difference between World Anvil and Campfire?
World Anvil combines worldbuilding, novel writing, RPG campaign management and publishing in one platform. Campfire focuses on novel writing, with a few basic modular worldbuilding tools. World Anvil’s broader feature set includes dedicated GM tools, automatic family trees, diplomacy webs and extensive options for visual customization, making it a stronger choice when your setting needs to support stories, games and attract an audience of readers.
Is World Anvil or Campfire better for writing novels?
World Anvil is especially well suited to novelists creating rich fantasy, science fiction or historical settings. Its Manuscripts editor combines chapter and scene planning, a corkboard and direct access to your world bible. Campfire also offers dedicated writing and planning tools. World Anvil’s advantage is the depth of the setting you can build around your books, from automatic family trees to histories connected to interactive maps. World Anvil supports series after series and also helps you with marketing and growing your fanbase.
Is Campfire or World Anvil better for D&D and other RPG campaigns?
Campfire has almost no support for D&D and other RPG campaigns. In contrast, World Anvil is extremely well equipped for running D&D and other tabletop RPG campaigns. It provides a live virtual DM screen, a dedicated campaign manager, and a library of system-specific character sheets and statblocks supporting 100+ RPG systems, all connected to your worldbuilding. Campfire can help with basic organization, but it doesn’t offer a comparable suite of dedicated tools for preparing, running and reporting on your RPG sessions.
Can I use World Anvil or Campfire for both novels and RPG campaigns?
Both tools have worldbuilding features, but only World Anvil provides dedicated tools for both novel writing and RPG campaign management. Write your fiction in the Manuscripts novel writing software, run your adventures with the RPG campaign manager, and draw on the same characters, locations and history.
How do World Anvil and Campfire’s worldbuilding tools compare?
World Anvil has significantly more support for worldbuilding, fiction writing and RPG Campaigns compared to Campfire. Both platforms offer tools for characters, locations, calendars, timelines and interactive maps. World Anvil adds specialist features such as automatic family trees, diplomacy webs and Chronicles, which connect historical events to locations on a map. For example, Campfire’s family trees use a basic, manually drawn flowchart system, while World Anvil generates contextual, interactive family trees from character relationships. That makes World Anvil especially useful for complex, interconnected settings.
Which is better for beginners: Campfire or World Anvil?
World Anvil is a great choice for beginners who want guidance as they build. Its worldbuilding templates include prompts to help you develop characters, places, cultures and more, while tutorials and community challenges provide support and inspiration. It also has a full course for beginners about how to start worldbuilding. And World Anvil was crafted by industry experts, so its custom built for creatives. On the other hand, Campfire offers little in the way of support for beginners. Choose World Anvil if you want guided worldbuilding that can grow into a novel, campaign or public world website.
How do World Anvil and Campfire’s free plans compare?
Both offer free accounts without a time limit. World Anvil’s free plan lets you build and share a public world with articles, maps, timelines and RPG statblocks, subject to usage limits. Campfire’s free plan includes limits for each worldbuilding module.
How do World Anvil and Campfire compare for publishing web novels and serial fiction?
World Anvil lets you publish web novels or release your serial fiction chapter by chapter. You can choose whether or not readers can leave comments. You can also choose exactly who sees what – from coauthors to beta and ARC readers to your Patreon supporters – and monetize your work chapter by chapter or novel by novel. On Campfire, you can’t publish your work yourself. It must undergo a review by the team and may not be released. You can also only monetize by completed novel, not chapter-by-chapter, meaning it's not a good venue for serial fiction. Campfire also takes a percentage fee from your monetization, which World Anvil does not.
Can I earn money from my writing with World Anvil or Campfire?
Yes. On World Anvil you have complete control over what you offer to your customers – exclusive chapters, bonus lore, deleted scenes, worldbuilding notes, even development update! You can crowdfund through Patreon or Kickstarter, sell access via your own storefront, and World Anvil will never take a percentage. Campfire allows authors to sell only completed books they have approved, and select story extras, for which it charges a percentage. You cannot sell serial fiction. They also have content restrictions on what kind of content you can sell. World Anvil is a strong fit if you want to use Patreon, Kickstarter, release and monetize serial fiction, or create a community around an ongoing story or fictional world.
Can I create a custom world website with World Anvil or Campfire?
World Anvil is the stronger choice for creating a custom world website as it has significantly more options than Campfire. On World Anvil you can customize your world’s appearance with visual themes and CSS, and use custom domain and white labeling to put your own brand first. You can even optimize your SEO and use Google Analytics! Campfire offers some themed projects and book pages within its platform; World Anvil gives you complete control over how your public world is presented and accessed.
Can I publish fanfiction on World Anvil or Campfire?
Campfire’s publishing rules prohibit sharing any fanfiction. World Anvil, though, supports sharing fanfiction, provided it follows basic copyright and etiquette rules. You can publish stories and build supporting character pages, maps and head-canon lore for readers to explore, and even connect with other fans.
What mature content can I publish on World Anvil and Campfire?
World Anvil allows mature fiction, including erotica, when it is correctly marked NSFW/18+ and follows content rules and community etiquette. If you find something you believe does not follow community guidelines, you can report it. Campfire, on the other hand, is much stricter about NSFW content and much of it cannot be published. They also have no NSFW filters to protect users.
Can I add audio books to my stories on World Anvil or Campfire?
Campfire does not support audiobooks, but World Anvil lets you pair your story with recorded audiobook instalments, chapter by chapter. Simply add an audio link to each Manuscripts chapter, and readers can listen through the embedded player while they read. This supports your own narration or a professional recording hosted elsewhere.
Which is better for getting new readers: World Anvil or Campfire?
World Anvil is designed to help you build a readership around your entire fictional world. You can release public lore as part of your marketing strategy to keep your readers engaged between instalments. And you can release a web novel or serial fiction to keep them coming back for more! You can create reader forums to chat with your readers, using discussion boards. Campfire doesn’t support serial fiction in the same way, and you’re more restricted in what you can publish, and how quickly. It also doesn’t have reader forums.